Comments on: Opinion: My Predictions for the Palm OS in 2002
Article Comments
(142 comments)
The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PalmInfocenter is not responsible for them in any way.
Please Login or register here to add your comments.
Comments Closed
This article is no longer accepting new comments.
RE: How about this...
2002 iPod PDA
RE: How about this...
RE: How about this...
RE: How about this...
RE: How about this...
> up Apple with a little $100M investment
Not really. The $100M investment was symbolic, didn't mean much for cash-rich Apple or Microsoft., and Microsoft has already sold all of that stock. Yet Apple continues -- in appropriate forums -- to be friendly with Microsoft because Apple needs to keep MS Office on the Mac. Jobs is smart enough to understand that, and has done an excellent job working with the Microsoft Macintosh Business Unit -- a division that has (ironically enough) produced some of the most Mac-like software that is out there. Go figure.
I predict that the iPod's capability will be expanded, but I don't see it becoming a Palm-like device. Apple realizes that there is not much money to be made in that sector right now.
Instead, I predict that Apple's focus on Palm will simply be to encourage development of Palm software compatability with Mac OS X. Steve Jobs tried to buy Palm a while back, and it would have been one thing for Apple to own this market, but without owning the market I don't see Apple making any Palm-like devices any time soon.
-Jeff
oh my god!
PDANature - http://pdan.has.it - Great hourly refreshed pda news, discussions, chat, reviews, commentarys, software, software update notices, features, and what not! Simply the best. http://pdan.has.it
RE: oh my god!
RE: oh my god!
RE: oh my god!
RE: oh my god!
---------------------------------------
When you have a Clie shoved up your mouth, you can only talk in vowels.
RE: oh my god!
Resolutions
RE: Resolutions
Tim Denton
Unlearn Grafitti? Did that years ago!
RE: Unlearn Grafitti? Did that years ago!
RE: Unlearn Grafitti? Did that years ago!
better than anything else, nice thing is that i dont have to move my hand across liek on a piece of paper...
Hmmmmm...
Also, I'd really hate to think that my 330's company will go the way of the dinosaurs. If you haven't tried one, you're not aware of the ease of AutoCF and the nice virt. grafitti. Not saying mine is the best (please don't flame me), just that it certainly isn't below the sealine of what's hot. It's not sexy, but it's not dead, either.
...In accordance with the prophecy...
Quik_Fix
quikfix@hotmail.com
RE: Hmmmmm...
The Handera 330 has a great monochrome screen... However... after seeing it and feeling it at CompUSA yesterday, I think it feels extremely cheaply constructed and physically weak. (Nice jog rocker, though)
While I do not agree with much of that which Mr. Mike has said, I do agree that Handera is on its way out. I seriously doubt that any company putting a handheld that cheap on the market can survive.
-Palm Man
RE: Hmmmmm...
I don't agree with that statement, but I do think they could have made it a bit more attractive looking.
The 330 I have has a stronger and sturdier case than my PalmIIIx had and was MUCH better than the cheap plastics that were in my Visor 2mb.
I believe that HandEra does have some promise because they have lead some of the best innovations lately in the PalmOS, but they do need to get the ball rolling on new products. A new model every 18 months just isn't going to cut it, especially when Sony is releasing a new model every 2-3 months (granted there isn't much innovation in each new release).
I like supporting the 'little guy' because more often then not, its the little guy that has the best service. They don't have the rigid policies in place that can make larger companies 'customer unfriendly'. Although I have never had to deal with HandEra support, I've heard good things about the customer service so I am not worried.
J.R.D.
Sacramento, CA
RE: Hmmmmm...
RE: Hmmmmm...
I'm just guessing, but i bet that handera would probably replace those with 3 working 330s if you asked. They should still be under warranty, unless you've tampered or abused them. I do have a few handhelds that are in my technology graveyard in the garage.
It seems with handhelds, no matter what company you go with there are people that are unlucky and have 3 or 4 bad units in a row. I had a PalmIIIx for several years without a problem (until I dropped it) and a coworker had 3 of them go bad in a matter of 4 months. I then got a visor 8mb and replaced it twice due to quality control issues before I moved on.
I guess its just the luck of the draw.
Aaron T.
NY, NY
RE: Hmmmmm...
RE: Hmmmmm...
...In accordance with the prophecy...
Quik_Fix
quikfix@hotmail.com
RE: Hmmmmm...
PDANature - http://pdan.has.it - Great hourly refreshed pda news, discussions, chat, reviews, commentarys, software, software update notices, features, and what not! Simply the best. http://pdan.has.it
RE: Hmmmmm...
This also explains why a demo unit at a store might seem cheaply constructed. One of the issues was an inferior grade of plastic to what Handera had specified (as I understand it).
As I said, current units should pose no problems and leave people very happy.
As far as product cycle, Handera seems only to release products that are revolutionary, rather than evolutionary upgrades like some vendors (*cough* Sony *cough*)
Can't wait for a color OS5 Handera. Don't count them out yet.
Just my $0.02 =)
RE: Hmmmmm...
RE: Hmmmmm...
I still think they have the best idea for a screen (the 320x240). if they could make an OS5 device that had a color version of that screen, and change the form factor, they'd sell tons.
(not that i have anything against the Palm III look, i loved my IIIxe until my batteries blew up in it. but after using a s320 for months now, i'm sold on the slimmer design.)
Very Technical but not Professional
You prabably know that but the fact you didn't list it makes people *THINK* that you don't know it.
I'm not picking on your article, but since it gets a name, you should introduce that as well.
More detail about Duo is here:
http://www.memorystick.org/msinfo/eng/ms/duo.html
RE: Very Technical but not Professional
Ridiculous in <no.2>
How would SONY (or any manufacturer) put that hard drive into a PDA? I mean in willingness, not discussing the diffculty.
It will be very weak in durability under the circumstance as how we use our PDA today!!
PDA is a PDA, not a "carrying computer" or "Mini Tablet PC", they're designed for different purpose, please do not try to move anything you see on other computer-related device to a "PDA" and make it gain size and weight, that wiould be terrible.
I hope the manufacturers do not think as the same way as you, otherwise we'll need a BIG carrying bag to carry our SUPER (HEAVY) PDA after 2002, which is not any Palm OS PDA user like to see!
RE: Ridiculous in <no.2>
Some people prefer to have something comparable to their computer that can fit in the palm of their hand. Would you like to haul around a laptop to school? Or would an average student have the money for a Picturebook?
RE: Ridiculous in <no.2>
RE: Ridiculous in <no.2>
RE: Ridiculous in <no.2>
RE: Ridiculous in <no.2>
RE: Ridiculous in
RE: Ridiculous in <no.2>
The Clie seems to run forever, even with the backlight on. The PPC runs out of juice very quickly, even with very light use.
RE: Ridiculous in
The Palm Conundrum:
-while at the same time:
Keep prices low, Keep Ease of Use, Keep Efficient Battery Usage, Keep Slim Size/Weight, and Support all Legacy Apps.
NOT AN EASY TASK TO DO BOTH AT THE SAME TIME!
funny, but no
RE: funny, but no
If Palm is going to flourish, these next 12 monthes are critical. If they let too much market share slip, they'll lose their foundation (developement base) that maintains them now.
Where is the new Palm CEO?
RE: funny, but no
RE: funny, but no
Scott
I think it's going to be bigger than that
RE: I think it's going to be bigger than that
Why Can't Macintosh Succeed When Their Stuff Is So Cool?
Thanks, Robrecht
RE: I think it's going to be bigger than that
RE: I think it's going to be bigger than that
How old are you, about 12? Go away, the adults are talking now. We'll be amused by your tricks later. it's past your bedtime.
RE: I think it's going to be bigger than that
http://www.dell.com/us/en/dhs/products/series_inspn_notebooks.htm#tn2
RE: I think it's going to be bigger than that
The best competitor, which is still only a concept, may be the Compaq Dual World convertible laptop, if they ever decide to manufacture it.
Check it out at http://makeashorterlink.com/?Z2921224
Thanks, Robrecht
RE: I think it's going to be bigger than that
Sorry but no.
While I actually think Palm will try much of what you mentioned, I don't think much or any of it will work.
Palm will only appear to improve, as it won't be messing things up as badly as it has the last year and a half.
The established base of users is large now, only compared to the current base of PDA users, not to the market as it is already trending and will exist as in the next five years.
Palm would have to be expect to win a war with underpowered software, smushed into hardware skewed towards the Pocket PC standard. Microsoft seems to have done too much to partner with its hardware makers, and pre-empt any move towards business, and is only gaining in the consumer market.
RE: Sorry but yes.
Remember where MS came from... A weedy DOS based Windows system that was technically inferior to all of the competition, but the one thing they did do right was to get it to the market just as demand required it and each step of the way they provided a path of backward compatibility.
RE: Sorry but no.
RE: Sorry but no.
RE: Sorry but no.
PDANature - http://pdan.has.it - Great hourly refreshed pda news, discussions, chat, reviews, commentarys, software, software update notices, features, and what not! Simply the best. http://pdan.has.it
RE: Sorry but no.
Outside posters
http://www2.pdabuzz.com/Forums/showthread.php?threadid=30223
RE: Outside posters
RE: Outside posters
RE: Outside posters
Hey, I cross-posted to your discussion! What more do you want from me?
RE: Outside posters
Great Editorial/opinion, Mike. I hope 2002 pans out that way...for all of us. Happy New Year!!!
RE: Outside posters
Hey, I never promised to be logical or even consistent. =+)
---
News Editor
RE: Outside posters
RE: Outside posters
RE: Outside posters
RE: Outside posters
Scott
Consumer market
Cell phones are an easy sell because everyone already uses a phone, and having one to carry around just makes sense to people. Adding simple features like text messaging to phones is also an easy sell, because people are used to pagers.
Most people I know don't have a PDA, and I am talking about white collar office workers in management positions. Cheap prices or more featurs aren't the answer. It's going to take a real marketing effort to educate the mass of consumers to the value of PDAs.
RE: Consumer market
Don't forget the already fielded hardware
The manufacturers of small mobile telephones made a shocking discovery in the spring of 2001. Joe and Mary six-pack are not going to want to replace their cellphones every six months. In fact, Joe and Mary get kind of upset when they realize they were the guinea pigs for developers that couldn't get it right the first time.
I am all for new hardware, and admit that I am likely to be one of those who convert quickly. Those new Sonys are looking very good compared to the M505 and the SD card just doesn't seem to be catching on.
However for the PDA business to become sustainable, they must realize that there is good money to be made on the existing user base. In fact it is this money that is necessary to pay all of the development dollars required to design the new ones.
For one player to emerge as a leader and earn brand loyalty they will have to find that balance of supporting their existing customers as well as providing them with aspirations of their next "insanely great" PDA.
It has to generate a profit or it is GAME OVER.
RE: Don't forget the already fielded hardware
RE: Don't forget the already fielded hardware
RE: Don't forget the already fielded hardware
RE: Don't forget the already fielded hardware
1.)They used industry standard memory expansion (CF, SD/MMC) instead of a proprietary memory stick.
2.) They would use a QVGA (also somewhat a standard when you factor in PPC's) instead of "pixel doubling" for their hi-res displays.
The Sony's color screens are beautiful. Too bad their obesession with proprietary hardware alienates me from buying their products.
Just my $0.02 =)
I wonder if they'll ever get over losing you as a customer..
proprietary memory stick
RE: Don't forget the already fielded hardware
I think Sony did a superb job with 320 by 320.
RE: Don't forget the already fielded hardware
Contrast that with the PPC OS. They just came out with PPC 2002. From my opinion, it's a relatively minor upgrade. However, from what I've read as a developer, it's quite easy for someone to create an app for a PPC 2002 device which simply won't run on an older device. MS has a habit of doing this sort of thing in the desktop world as well, but at least there you can usually "make due" and upgrade the OS on older hardware. Here you're stuck. I just don't see people buying into this once they discover this trend.
Scott
Palm -> PPC
Microsoft got the whole PPC thing actually right for once, and Palm is lagging behind. If they can get ALL of those things done in 2002, I will have great respect for them. But, real life says... "it aint gonna happen"
That was a real cute article, but half of it wont happen. Palm is going through so much s@%# right now, they wont be able to pull themselves together.
RE: Palm -> PPC
YEAH - I heard MSFT stole Graffiti from XEROX.
RE: Palm -> PPC
RE: Palm -> PPC
The way I see it, eveything's got be blanced. What do I mean by that?
Someone else on this board already said that MS tends to keep good complibility with it's OS and I guess this goes for PPCs as well. From a Windows programer's point of view, wirtting code for PPC much the same as writting code for Windows. So by next year when Intel's Xscle based PPCs are going at 400Mhz, PPCs can actually replace some laptops by having the ability to run some desktop apps.
So having a complex OS may not be that bad in this case. On the other hand, when Palm puts all the multimedia and connectivity stuff that PPC have into the new OS, Palm will grow in size and will need lots more house power to run.
RE: Palm -> PPC
10 Dragonballs = 1 ARM?
RE: Palm -> PPC
Scott
Why not a built in TV tuner?
Star Trekkers of the world, unite!
Hey, what is the difference between Trekkies and Trekkers, anyway?
RE: Why not a built in TV tuner?
SIZE. Palm's would turn into Laptops (size wise).
RE: Why not a built in TV tuner?
RE: Why not a built in TV tuner?
RE: Why not a built in TV tuner?
RE: Why not a built in TV tuner?
#12
#12. Carl Yankowski, intent on proving that "simple is better," signs a multi-million dollar deal to be CEO of PaperPalm, Inc.
http://www.brighthand.com/palmhandhelds/reviews/devices/paperpalm.html. However, that venture runs into trouble when consumers realize the device's multimedia limitations (largely limited to the animation of stick figures). The company also becomes mired in litigation with the Cross and FaberCastell companies over PalmPalm's apparent patent infringement by its incorporation of a carbon-based No. 2 input device. Furthermore, developers in the company are unable to perfect the syncronization software. Yankowski resigns in a flurry of criticism, as the company spins off a Big Chief Tablet division.
JBH
Gee Mike
By the way I thought you went to the Dark Side and embraced Microsofts PC's
bye
RE: Gee Mike
RE: Gee Mike
RE: Gee Mike
:)
But I like him. Does anyone like me?
RE: Gee Mike
RE: Gee Mike
Thanks, Robrecht
RE: Gee Mike
RE: Gee Mike
To post 100 or more messages a day and spend several hours daily pouring over these site is pathological. If you feel he is rude, think of his posting as a cry for help from a sick individual. Cane deserves our pity - his actions are due more to mental illness than they are to a personality disorder.
RE: Gee Mike
Mike "Virtual Graffiti" Cane!
RE: Mike
Call Psychic Friends Network
The biggest boner in your list is Springboard being dropped. The only reason why the Trio has no Springboard slot is that the cell phone network carriers have publically stated that they do not allow open buses on their network. Springboard is alive and well with the release of the Pro and Neo. How do you want your crow cooked?
RE: Call Psychic Friends Network
Why no allow open buses on their network?
Rumours of the Springboards Demise are greatly exaggerated
The Springboard slot is a fantastic idea. It offers expansion possibilities that now other handheld can touch. The springboard idea may evolve over time, but I doubt it will be killed off.
Doug
RE: Call Psychic Friends Network
RE: Call Psychic Friends Network
Springboard modules are here to stay.
Repeat after me: Expansion Expansion Expansion
Any questions, think Apple II....Mac....newest Macs and why the PC really succeeded....
Resolution is a very important upgrade.
Hard disks, etc. are WRONG...Why???? These are PDAs, not PCs, laptops, or Sun workstations. Palm, Handspring, etc. must keep this in mind. It is very important. All my Palm user friends and I agree the purpose of the PDA is low power, fast access to recurring useful information, not a replacement for a laptop or desktop.
Lastly, my PDA can do things that a Pentium 4 PC can never ever accomplish....and vice versa....they each have their place.
Mike Wikinson
I thought a lot about your points and.....
Sony/Mac Booster
I think Palm will go out of business.
I think Sony will continue to amaze us, by making the current products better. What always amazes me is how foreign companies keep making our stuff better? Why is that do they care more about our needs any wants then the American companies? I certainly hope not but I tend to believe that is the case...
RE: I think Palm will go out of business.
RE: I think Palm will go out of business.
I'm sorry, but I give Handspring less time than Palm.
JBH
RE: I think Palm will go out of business.
You're not the only one, but some people have predicted/hoped for palm to go out of business and handspring/sony to lead. Where exactly does the OS come from for their 'palmOS' handhelds?
Microsoft Reader???
Mike Cane
Handspring & Springboard modules
"Super CLIE"
There are several HD-based MP3 players right now. The iPod is unique in that it reads a song -- sometimes several -- off the HD, puts it (them) in RAM, shuts off the HD, and plays from RAM. It has a ten-hour battery life -- damned good for an HD-based player; and even better than *all* PPCs used to play MP3 from solid-state cards!
Now note that *multimedia* is usually *not* mission-critical stuff for most of us. It is generally Fun Stuff -- and backup copies (as the original source) exist on our Macs & PCs.
In much the same way, the HD of an "HD-ed CLIE" would be used to store multimedia and data that is archival in nature (ie, ebooks, photos). Just because my predicted "Super CLIE" has an HD does not mean there won't be an MStick slot for dynamic data (Date Book, et al). The HD would work like the iPod -- spin, dump, shut off. And since the data is read-only, no need to wake the HD for Saves.
As for playing full-length movies on this predicted "Super CLIE," I leave that to the Wizards of Sony to work out (ie, RAM-buffering ala iPod to save power).
As for form factor, I believe Sony could do it in the existing N-series size. The iPod's dimensions as an MP3 player should not be confused with a PDA's dimensions. And I leave it up to the completists here to cite cubic inches of the iPod vs N6/7xx. I think they'll show a strong similarity.
Here are the raw dimensions --
iPod
4.02" x 2.43" x 0.78" - 6.5 oz
Sony N-series CLIE
4 3/4" x 2 7/8" x 11/16" - 5.65 oz
(Being math-impaired, I won't even try to decimalize fractions! Or fractionalize decimals.)
RE:
RE:
RE:
Clip that onto the back of a T600C and add battery space to the bottom half on back and there you have it. An Ipod killer, with PDA included, for $500.
Another Prediction true!
http://www.handera.com/press/palmos.asp
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
HANDERA ISSUES EOL NOTICE FOR HANDERA 330 AND TRGPRO PRODUCTS
DES MOINES, Iowa – April 16, 2003 – HandEra today issued an End Of Life (EOL) notice for both of its Palm OS based handheld products, the TRGpro and HandEra 330. Due to cost increases associated with licensing the OS, HandEra will no longer be able to ship products containing the Palm OS after May 31st.
"We regret the impact that this announcement will have on our customers," said Mark Kubovich, President of HandEra. "HandEra will offer new products to serve the OEM mobile computing market in the near future."
Limited stock of the HandEra 330 is available to fulfill last time buy orders. Last time buy orders will be considered on a case by case basis.
About HandEra
HandEra, Inc. is a leading provider of software, electrical, and mechanical engineering services for a broad range of industries including mobile computing, industrial controls and consumer products.
Founded in 1992, the company previously operated under the name TRG Products, Inc. HandEra is a privately held company based in Des Moines, Iowa.
###
HandEra and HandEra 330 are registered trademarks of HandEra, Inc. Palm OS is a registered trademark and Palm Powered is a trademark of Palm, Inc. or its subsidiaries. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Latest Comments
- I got one -Tuckermaclain
- RE: Don't we have this already? -Tuckermaclain
- RE: Palm brand will return in 2018, with devices built by TCL -richf
- RE: Palm brand will return in 2018, with devices built by TCL -dmitrygr
- Palm phone on HDblog -palmato
- Palm PVG100 -hgoldner
- RE: Like Deja Vu -PacManFoo
- Like Deja Vu -T_W
How about this...
I have a hard time believing palm OS 5 will work so well given the headaches involved in getting expansion memory to work.
Apple will not release a audrey like device which would cannibalize iMac and iBook sales while providing thousands of support headaches on a low margin device.