PalmV Bridge Review
By Robert Zach
Palm has Plans for new products every 6 months according to
their S-1 filing. So looks like I have six months to save my pennies! But,
replacing all those peripherals, that's a different story. Well for $15 I can now use my
Palm III accessories with my PalmVx.
MidWest PCB designs has conceived a very simplistic approach to doing this. Use
this little brick of plastic.

When attached to the bottom of my PalmVx the whole set-up appears non-intrusive.

The Bridge functions quiet well during HotSync operations and I was able to verify the functionality of a number of third part hardware devices. The product simply works!
Just as described.
What I found a little disconcerting is what happens to the sleek profile of the PalmVx
once the Palm V Bridge is attached.

Due to the Palm Inc.'s design of the port , and the straight line PCB style
construction by MidWest, the device actually protrudes significantly from the unit.
This makes keeping the Bridge attached during transportation clumsy. Also,
the flat PCB designed contacts could short if left attached to the device in your pocket.
As the MidWest web site says, the fit with third party add-ons is tight. Very
Tight! In struggling to remove the device I actually stuck myself on the solder pins
sticking through the PCB.
Also, due entirely to Palm's design of the PalmVs serial port, although Palm III
devices fit snug onto the Brige, sticking that mass onto the Palm V doesn't make a snug
fit. So with devices like keyboards (with the Palm now having a higher center of
balance) the PalmV/Bridge combo tends to wiggle a little making the unit a little unstable
on say the GoType Keyboard.
Well all of this must be already known because MidWest PCB Designs let me know that
they have a clip-on type system under development. These types of devices appear
more stable as a "portable" solution. And, they tend to put more of the
"attaching mechanism" in contact with the add-on peripheral. I also hope
the clip-on relieves the tightness a little, snug should be good enough for attaching
devices.
So where do I think the BEST use of the Palm V Bridge is then? If not attached to
the Palm V, the best place the Bridge can be for me is to have one permanently attached to
my home Palm III HotSync, and a second one attached to my HotSync travel cable.

This is where the diminutive size and simplicity of a non-clip-on device excels.
I plan on keeping the bridge permanently attached to the HotSync cable and stashed
safely away in my travel bag for quick on-the-road syncs and occasional OS upgrades!
Absolutely perfect!

I gave the Palm V bridge it's rating based on the usefulness of the product and clever
idea. The coolness factor rating is based on the fact that the bridge is an
elegantly simple "little chunk of plastic". It really conjures up the
notion "why didn't I think of that?"
I can't wait to see how tricky they can get in designing a clip-on. ;-)
|
Why can't Palm standardize on one set of connectors. The stuff above lists for over $500 in addition to an investment in Palm. I'd hate to throw all this away. And I don't like the idea of a tacky bridge, but will consider it if it preserves the utility of these add-ons. Resale of these peripherals will suck as they always do.
Thanks for listening.
Ina