MobileInfocenter

Comments on: New Clear Flip Cases for the T3 and Zire 71

Javoedge has a interesting set of new cases out for the Tungsten T3 and Zire 71. They are a clear plastic that wrap around the handheld for protection that also features a flip cover.
Return to Story - Permalink

Article Comments

 (28 comments)

The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PalmInfocenter is not responsible for them in any way.
Please Login or register here to add your comments.

Comments Closed Comments Closed
This article is no longer accepting new comments.

Down

Scratches

Gekko @ 3/4/2004 3:47:32 PM #
If it scratches up like the T1, T2 cover, I won't like it.


RE: Scratches
rory @ 3/4/2004 7:12:13 PM #
It looks nice, but I've been a Mac user long enough to know that anything shiny and transparent will show up scratches like there's no tomorrow ;) Still it does protect the PDA while allowing you access to the buttons and see the screen so I imagine it would be handy. I'd really like to see PalmOne put a detachable flip cover on the next multimedia Zire, like on my Sony Clie SJ30, I really like having a protective cover which doesn't make the PDA any bulkier in my pocket.

--
Visor Deluxe > iPod > Clie SJ33 > Zire 71 > ?
RE: Scratches
iJITSU @ 3/5/2004 10:43:33 AM #
I think the point is that your case gets scratched instead of your pda. Too Funny. Some want to use a case for their pda so that they don't scratch it, then worry about scratching the case? Now, where can I find that case for my PDA case that protects your pda case from getting scratched.....?

RE: Scratches
adc5x @ 3/5/2004 12:45:34 PM #
iJITSU- I think the point is that the case *shows* the scratches. It's nice to have a case that protects your Palm from getting scratched, but some cases (those made of leather or metal) don't get scratched themselves. The whole point of having a clear plastic is that you can see through it, but the clear cases that came with the T|T and T2 got so scratched up as to be unusable after a week.

So the question is whether this clear case can protect your Palm, while still looking good. Otherwise why not just get a metal case?

RE: Scratches
iJITSU @ 3/8/2004 9:43:49 PM #
My answer would be yes. I never had a problem with the clear case that came with the T and T2. It got small scratches, but never became unusable thus it was much better than a metal case in that you could see data without opening the case. But that was just my preference. I know people who prefer leather, others metal. Whatever works. I just thought it was funny to worry about scratches on something designed to protect something else from scratches.

RE: Scratches
Gekko @ 3/10/2004 10:00:35 PM #
scratches obscure visibility of screen is the point.

Perfect Accessory for my Palm Zire 71

rav @ 3/4/2004 3:46:04 PM #
This is the absolute PERFECT accessory for my Palm Zire 71. Just placed an order for the flip case online. Why didn't anyone think of this sooner...?
RE: Perfect Accessory for my Palm Zire 71
dsamuilov @ 3/4/2004 4:39:33 PM #
They did... with the original T|T, and everyone complained about it. I don't see these covers really taking off since they can get scratched easilly and if they break, a sharp piece of plastic may puncture/scratch/break the screen, even with a screen protector.

RE: Perfect Accessory for my Palm Zire 71
smap77 @ 3/5/2004 1:05:03 AM #
As a lover of my T|T clear cover I'd probably go for one of these--but I still have my T|T! (Anyone know where I can get a replacement?)

RE: Perfect Accessory for my Palm Zire 71
Altema @ 3/5/2004 1:11:20 PM #
Replacement T|T, or replacement cover? I tried to get another cover when mine was lost, but could not find any at the time. If I find any I'll post a link here.

I did not like using two hands the get that cover off, but it did the job. The problem I had is that a little peice of grit between the cover and the case would grind its way through the finish on the Palm, leaving a permanent mark.

RE: Perfect Accessory for my Palm Zire 71
Boogaboo @ 3/5/2004 6:38:54 PM #
dsamuilov, I think that any action that would result in the breaking of a plasic flip cover would have most certainly resulted in the breaking of the actual screen if it had not had a flip cover. I would rather have a flip cover break than the actual PDA, and I think that is the point of having this as an option.

Boogaboo

anyone know if you can do a cradle sync ...

dirkpitt @ 3/4/2004 4:40:02 PM #
in the case? it's not clear from their site ... looks cool. I have a Bellagio case that has served me well, but this would be a lot smaller.

RE: anyone know if you can do a cradle sync ...
Altema @ 3/4/2004 10:45:03 PM #
The case covers the back, so fitting in the cradle on the Z71 is a no, and same for the T3 when the slider is closed. You MIGHT be able to get the T3 to fit in the cradle if you expand it and position it carefully. It will not sit in the cradle in the correct position, but it may sync. Best advice is to ask the company if it will work, or see if they will take the case back if it does not work. Still, it looks like a cool alternative and a good design.

RE: anyone know if you can do a cradle sync ...
4s @ 3/4/2004 11:48:07 PM #
I have this case for the T3 and it syncs fine in the cradle when the T3 is extended.

<><
RE: anyone know if you can do a cradle sync ...
Altema @ 3/5/2004 12:54:02 PM #
That's good to hear, thanks for the confirmation.

Tungsten T case

s_teve @ 3/4/2004 4:44:37 PM #
Does anyone know if these covers will be released for the Tungsten T, it is an awful pain using the supplied platic cover and the cases are much too bulky

RE: Tungsten T case
Khris @ 3/4/2004 7:05:54 PM #
I like my Proporta T2 case the best from all the ones I've seen so far!

If you haven't seen one yourself, check it out.

RE: Tungsten T case
GearHead @ 3/4/2004 10:58:30 PM #
Maybe you can use this case for TT or T2 as well as T3. I am not sure about this case though. Buttons are stil there easy to acidental activation.
I personally own a Krussel case for my TT and for my Sprint Treo 600. Both cases are very slim and works just perfect. Good Luck!

Free 802.11 No More Wires!!!
Support your local WAN!
RE: Tungsten T case
iJITSU @ 3/5/2004 10:46:44 AM #
The T3 has a key lock so that the buttons do not launch when locked.

Looks good, but....

achitnis @ 3/5/2004 12:18:37 AM #
Looks good, but I see a lot of gottchas (some have been described above):

  1. Cannot charge/Sync in cradle when in the case (and no keyboard access, either)

  2. No storage for additional stuff (visiting/credit cards, SD cards)

  3. No padding of any sort (drop it, and its gone)

  4. The holes for the buttons shouldn't have been there (dust collectors, accidental activation)

  5. The back looks ugly (only the front should have been clear plastic)

  6. Access to stylus is badly designed (can still lose stylus with case closed - why expose stylus if you cant use it with the case closed?)

  7. Overpriced.


Atul Chitnis
http://atulchitnis.net

RE: Looks good, but....
iJITSU @ 3/5/2004 10:47:40 AM #
But compared to a bulky leather case that totally defeats the advantage of having a sleek pda, this is a better solution for some.

RE: Looks good, but....
Altema @ 3/5/2004 12:56:26 PM #
They also make a unique leather case which would probably fit your needs better. They have better protection and space for expansion cards in a position that does not hit the screen, and it comes with a belt clip. I think the clear case is for those that don't want the extra bulk, but I don't know why they covered the back either. I have tried the metal cases, but some make your device almost twice as thick.

Me? I use the stock leather flip, but sometimes I'll even take that off and just have my BoxWave screen protector as the only protection. After going for the maximum PDA/minimum size combo, I did not want to wrap it up in a big metal contraption!

RE: Looks good, but....
4s @ 3/5/2004 1:48:42 PM #
Again, T3 CAN be synced in the case and it works perfectly in the Palm Portable Keyboard. The screen cover even stays open.

And no. I don't work for Javoedge. I just happen to have this case. :)

<><

RE: Looks good, but....
skeezix @ 3/5/2004 4:21:56 PM #
Course, if you want overpriced, yet perfect, cases.. go to Vaja leather cases... sweeeeeeeeet :) (I picked up for my T|T1 a vaja leather magnetic clousire flip top case.. super sleek, and fits T|T2 fine. For T|T3 I still use it, though ther buttons dont' line up quite right..)

jeff

The Shadow knows!

RE: Looks good, but....
DevPOV @ 3/6/2004 5:30:35 PM #
Vaja cases are great! I don't think they are overpriced as they tend to be handmade for each order. And the quality is absolutely the best I've seen of any case.

Probably Security Related

rcartwright @ 3/5/2004 12:24:58 PM #
I long for a Palm IIIxe form factor with the flip top. That said, I suspect that the clear plastic covers are to indicate what is inside, so some TSA chimp (no offense intended to that branch of the primate family) does not think you are pulling a gun or something. Kind of like the clear plastic or net backpacks that some schools require. Otherwise, I have no clue why anyone would really want a clear plastic cover.

Life is a great adventure or nothing.
RE: Probably Security Related
Davy Fields @ 3/8/2004 12:44:28 AM #
The buttons are exposed... it's the same reason the buttons were exposed on PalmOne's original Tungsten T plastic cover, so that you can look up some quick bit of information without opening up the case or even needing more than one hand to use it.

I think it's very practical.

-Davy Fields
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Palm_OS_5/

RE: Probably Security Related
iJITSU @ 3/8/2004 9:50:09 PM #
Has nothing to do with security, and everything to do with ease of use.

Top

Account

Register Register | Login Log in
user:
pass: