MobileInfocenter

Comments on: Palm Treo 650 Review

The Treo 650 is the third incarnation of the Treo smartphone series. It builds upon the successes of it's past siblings and adds many requested features and enhancements. Read on for the full review.
Return to Story - Permalink

Article Comments

 (28 comments)

The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PalmInfocenter is not responsible for them in any way.
Please Login or register here to add your comments.

Start a new Comment Down

RE: Woo Hoo!

Frenchie @ 3/29/2005 7:43:45 PM # Q
Good review. Oh and there are wifi drivers availible ;) Shadomite did an awesome job getting the T5 drivers to work on the 650. A suggestion, could you add a link to the page that Mr. Kessler has so willingly written. Good job again.

The world will end in 2006. Just as it was predicted in the bible along with the release of Microsoft Longhorn.... :p
Reply to this comment

Shame on you PalmOne!

lorettaboy @ 3/29/2005 9:22:56 PM # Q
32MB of RAM is simply a joke.
No Wifi? Please! PalmOne is about 2-3 years behind every other handheld manufacturer in this regard.
A .3 MP digital camera? With other phones now having 5-7MP cameras, this really makes the new treo look bad.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
twizza @ 3/29/2005 10:05:43 PM # Q
For the target market, they either dont know what the rest are doing, or dont care.

Outside of those that frequent boards, you rarely hear the too little space argument.

The 650's camera at .3 is tons better than most any camera, except for a few, stress that few, Nokias. PalmOne did a great job with making a camera that takes quality pics and wont kill your $$ when you go MMS with it.

antoinerjwright.com

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
LiveFaith @ 3/29/2005 11:08:34 PM # Q
5-7mpx on a phone! Link please?

Pat Horne; www.churchoflivingfaith.com
RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
joad @ 3/29/2005 11:49:29 PM # Q
I believe this is one of the best overall reviews of the 650 I've read. The memory problems are even acknowledged.

But enough about the 650... anyone have any good rumors on the Treo 700 yet? Springtime's here!!!

7 Megapixel cameras on phones? You betcha...
The_Voice_of_Reason @ 3/30/2005 2:11:46 AM # Q
5-7mpx on a phone! Link please?

www.google.com

Does your Mama still wipe your bottom, too? Google is your friend, man.

“Give a man a fish; you have fed him for today. Teach a man to fish; and you have fed him for a lifetime.”

TVoR's Razor: "Teach a lazy biotch to use Google and maybe you won't have to see as many useless questions from him/her as the Lord now forces us to endure."

Can I get an "Amen", Brothers and Sisters? Glory, Hallelujah!

------------------------------------------------------------------------------


http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml?type=technologyNews&storyID=7848282

http://www.digitalcamerareview.com/default.asp?newsID=2411

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

And to give you an idea what Palm is competing with (and why Palm doesn't appear to have a hope in Hell), take a look at these phones:

http://www.infosyncworld.com/news/n/5827.html

http://www.infosyncworld.com/news/n/5850.html

http://www.mobileburn.com/news.jsp?Page=1&Id=873

Nokia, Sony Ericsson, Samsung, Motorola, etc. don't fcuk around. They're going to eat Palm alive.







*************************************************************************************

Press release: CUPERTINO, California — February 11, 2005 — Apple® announced today that Steve Jobs will begin selling his own feces to Apple Cultists beginning March 1. Apple's new iPoo™ lineup is expected to easily surpass the iPod shuffle as the company's most popular product. Yes, Apple Cultists can already easily create their own iPoo™, but feces didn't seem cool until Jobs told them it was cool. Remember, kids: the ONLY cool feces is Jobs' highly individualistic, rebellious iPoo™ (coming soon in six different colors/flavors, including the red [hematochezia] and black [melena] U2 GI bleed model)

*************************************************************************************





******************************************************************
Sony CLIE UX100: 128 MB real RAM, OLED screen. All the PDA anyone really ever wanted.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
MovableTechnology51 @ 3/30/2005 8:08:50 AM # Q
I've never read such drivel in all my life. Maybe when you learn to type will your posts seem intelligent. Maybe you're just an employee of the other companies and you're trying to do a "hatchet job" on PalmOne.

All of the above devices have problems working in the US either because of network problems and a lack of software. Treo has one singular advantage over ANY Windoze device and that is the availability of third party software. I've used both PocketPC devices and Palmone and the Treo wins hands down. I don't trust Windoze on my PC, why should I trust it run on my phone? The same critique goes for Blackberry, a really stupid device. My wife's cousin could not use a Blackberry for infrared beaming of a phone number even though the Blackberry has an infrared port!

To all those who critize PalmOne for not building in a WiFi radio, my response is: have you checked the availability of Wifi sites lately? There are few Wifi sites except within the major US cities, and those of us who live in the country find Wifi useless. The Treo 650 from Cingular works even in the country.

I rest my case.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
scyber @ 3/30/2005 8:25:14 AM # Q
Ahhhh.. yes, I always forget that technology from 5 months ago is supposed to match technology from the past month.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
relyons @ 3/30/2005 9:55:48 AM # Q
Read those links from "The Voice."

I quickly discovered that "The Voice" is comparing the camera in a product available today (Treo 650) to the cameras in products that aren't available in this country or aren't available period.

The Samsung seven megapixel hasn't been released anywhere. The Samsung five megapixel is only available in Korea.

The LG phones are just announcements. They aren't available anywhere.

The Sony cameras are previews. They aren't available anywhere.

RTFA yourself and discover how "The Voice" misleads people.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
dstrauss @ 3/30/2005 2:42:12 PM # Q
RGHT ON. Look at the "Great" Samsung i550; announced almost 18 months ago; multi-megapixel, OS5, hi-res - you name it - and now CANCELLED by Samsung before it even hit the street. COmpare apples to apples folks. The 650 has been on the street since NOVEMBER 2004 - where are all these hot shots you're comparing to the 650?

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
Calroth @ 3/30/2005 6:57:10 PM # Q
Guess why there is a camera on the Treo 650?

TO SEND PHOTOS TO OTHER MOBILE PHONE USERS.

Its primary purpose is NOT to replace your digital camera, it is NOT to take high-quality photos, and it is NOT to win photography contests. It is to send via MMS to other mobile phones, thus earning money for your telco.

Given that, what the hell is the point of a higher-resolution camera? Sure, a camera with better quality for the same resolution is fine, which is what PalmOne did when upgrading from 600 to 650. But there is no way that you can send a 1MB 2048x1536 pixel image over the phone network to your buddies.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
lorettaboy @ 4/1/2005 8:54:30 AM # Q
"Its primary purpose is NOT to replace your digital camera, it is NOT to take high-quality photos, and it is NOT to win photography contests. It is to send via MMS to other mobile phones, thus earning money for your telco."

Its NOT all of those things simply because it's quality is pretty terrible.

"Given that, what the hell is the point of a higher-resolution camera?"

The point of having a higher-resolution camera in a phone, IS to replace your dedicated digatal camera. The several products mentioned above are evidence enough of this. If you have a 5MP camera in your phone, why would you need another digital?

don't wish for big worthless numbers
hotpaw4 @ 4/3/2005 3:58:20 PM # Q
Megapixel count is irrelevant if the lens can't resolve that detail. A so-called 5 megapixel camera with a small aperature diffraction limited lens just wastes memory. A high resolution lens is big (it's a simple law of physics). Most people like their cell phones small and thin.
RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
Calroth @ 4/3/2005 6:50:45 PM # Q
"The point of having a higher-resolution camera in a phone, IS to replace your dedicated digatal camera. The several products mentioned above are evidence enough of this. If you have a 5MP camera in your phone, why would you need another digital?"

This would be all well and good if YOU dictated the requirements of the camera.

However, you do not!

The telephone companies do. Why? Because they are the ones making money off this every time somebody sends an MMS. They are the ones giving PalmOne a kickback for including a camera. And they sure as hell do not want 5MP images going across their data networks.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
Calroth @ 4/3/2005 6:53:21 PM # Q
I should also say that PalmOne would rather DROP the camera than introduce a 5MP one. Why? Because businesses do not want it. Because it costs extra money to put one in (especially an expensive 5MP one). And because they already offer a camera-free option, so it would be simpler for them to drop the camera option and only offer one choice.

RE: Shame on you PalmOne!
billjw @ 4/22/2005 9:04:14 PM # Q
Interesting perspectives from everyone.

Just as a thought what are the specs on the Samsung et al camera phones with regards to their PIM functions?

I am assuming they have a pretty robust OS too? I hope so cos I'll look into it more seriously if they do.

Bill

Reply to this comment

competitors

oneself @ 3/30/2005 5:37:00 AM # Q
Whould be very good to make review of TREO with present and future competitors=)

iPaq6340 (haha)
http://www.hpc.ru/devices/img/4/498_00.gif

BenQ P50
http://www.hpc.ru/devices/img/5/546_00.jpg

HPC great new device
http://www.hpc.ru/devices/img/5/523_00.jpg

I personally do not see any _real_ competitors to 650. Hi-res, Bluetooth, SD, great one hand operation, qwerty and palm OS together in one device? PRICELESS!=)

RE: competitors
lorettaboy @ 3/30/2005 10:31:58 AM # Q
You don't see these devices as good competition, come on?
The Benq device has twice the RAM, larger screen, Wifi, and a superior 1.3MP camera.
HP Mobile Messenger HW6715 will have 64MB RAM, 520MHz processor, 1.3MP camera, Bluetooth, Wifi, and GPS built-in!
If these aren't good examples of decent competition, then I don't know what is?
And let's not get into the whole "why do people want wifi in their devices" argument. The simple fact of the matter is, people DO want wifi in these devices. This is why thousands of users switched to PPC devices when the T5 came out.
Deny it all you want, PalmOne is notorious for releasing new products with specs. you would expect from devices 2 years ago.

RE: competitors
jamesgood72 @ 3/30/2005 11:31:22 AM # Q
Loretaboy,

You can't compare the amount of RAM on PalmOS and PPC devices... I consider myself a power user, and yet haven't had problems with the amount of RAM in my T650.

Wifi? My UX50 had it, and it was nice, but only because GPRS was so slow through BT on my T68i. Saying that, the only thing I used Wifi for was hotsyncing. I haven't yet felt the need for Wifi on the Treo, since the Edge GPRS is quick enough for web browsing on that small screen. Always on email via Edge is much quicker than on demand checking via Wifi.

Obviously, the danger is PalmOS efficiency is losing out in the 'feature comparison wars'.

What device do you use on a day to day basis?

-James.

RE: competitors
lorettaboy @ 3/30/2005 12:17:03 PM # Q
Hey James,
I am currently using an HP hx2750 for my daily needs. It has 128MB of RAM and is the fastest handheld device on the market. I use wifi, on average, about 2 hours per day.
The only problem with using GPRS for internet is that it costs $20-$30/month (unlimited) on top of the normal cell plans, whereas wifi is almost always free. In Canada, where wifi has not caught on as much as in the US, my university still has about 30 AP's on campus.
Also, in Canada, cell phone carriers do not yet have unlimited data plans like US carriers do. Here in Ottawa for instance, we pay $25 for only 4MB of activity. I do more than 4MB of activity using my wifi on a daily basis.

RE: competitors
jamesgood72 @ 3/30/2005 1:29:36 PM # Q
Hey Loretaboy,

Yeah, I have unlimited data, so it's really convenient. Whereever I am, I can use the Internet, and my email comes at me!

So what kind of Internet access are you doing for 2 hours? Just general browsing?

THe one thing I wish I had more RAM for would be cache within Blazer (the browser). That should have the option of using my SD card.

-James.

RE: Competitors
Chanbingo @ 12/2/2005 2:19:17 AM # Q
You can't compaire PPC to Palm RAM amout. I have been a real poweruser of Palm handhelds for years and now the Treo 650 for six months. 32 MB means a lot for Palm applications. For media files you can use up to 2GB SD card storage without a fuss.

I have had had hands on experiences with most recent Nokia models. The things is you can't compaire Treo 650 to those phone or PDA since this is converged device.

Only now there are NOKIA and SE models coming out which are on far with Treo 650.

See: http://www.gsmarena.com/nokia_e61-1322.php

If you consider having a PC on your hand that has phone features then only think of Treo 650.

See more: http://handytools.blogspot.com/

Cheers!

Life is a rollercoaster. I love the free fall!

Reply to this comment

Versamail = bad email client.

jamesgood72 @ 3/30/2005 10:02:14 AM # Q
Pretty good review, although I think you should have concentrated more on the supplied software. That's what makes the hardware useful...

When I got my phone, to be honest, I was almost dissapointed. The problems were with the supplied software. Versamail was completely rubbish, kept crashing, very unstable. How could they ship a wireless smart phone with such a bad email client?

Then I found Chatteremail! I have to say, the Treo is the best thing I've bought in ages now. Always on, push email is the best, and Chatter is nice and stable. Works well with one handed operation, and is memory efficient. Why Palm have not snapped up this software is beyond me.

The SMS client shipped with the device was pretty good though. Quick, usable, nice looking and creates a log of all your messages, organised by sender.

The Real MP3 player was pretty bad. Pockettunes does a very good job though, and was much more usable on the 650 compared to how it was on the UX50. Use it all the time, hooked up my MINI's H/K audio system.

Documents to Go is pretty good, although a bit memory hungry. I can easily my pilots log book in it's native Excel format, which is pretty cool. I haven't tried the work processor part very much - I usually just use the memopad.

The much hyped (usually by people who don't use PalmOS machines any more) memory problems were not even close to being an issue, and that was after syncing my 7 years worth of Palm data. All my pictures, MP3s and Emulator ROMS went on my 1GB SD cards.

With the Versamail sync, and DTG sync, the Hotsync is getting a little bloated. Pity about that.

Battery life has been excellent, even with Chatteremail connected all the time. With about an hour of MP3 playing per day, and always on email, plus usual PDA use, I can easily run for one day (with plenty of reserve) or just about push to two days without charging.

-James.

RE: Versamail = bad email client.
rgg55 @ 2/10/2006 8:38:20 PM # Q
Your knowledge and experience with the 650 leads me to think you may be able to answer my question. For the last 2 years, I've been using my m515 to keep statistics at my son's baseball games on a software app called 'Scorekeeper." (The data is then loaded into separate software on my laptop where it is broken down, compiled, etc.) In the course of a game, I'll make between 3 and 10 entries per pitch, for a total of 500 or more per game. My 515 would handle two games a day, sometimes 4 per weekend, with only an overnight charge (if I kept the backlighting on the screen off.) Alas, the 515 is on its last microchip and i'm considerine the 650 smartphone, to kill a number of birds with one stone. My questions are (1) will the 650 hold up to this kind of use and (2) is the screen visible in sunlight with backlight reduced or turned off? Any help you can offer would be appreciated. Thanks.

rgg55

Reply to this comment

Data manager fixed yet?

Tuckermaclain @ 4/2/2005 8:12:23 PM # Q
It is unuseable to me with the bugs in the data manager patch. Any word on if it was fixed yet?

Reply to this comment

Phone features are incomplete

hodari @ 6/27/2005 3:06:17 PM # Q
Having read the review, I went out and bought a GMS unlocked TREO 650. I have used SonyEricson P800 and P900 - brilliant phones but less on PDA.

I started using the TREO650 and taking it for a spin. Some issues:

1. I tried to send a contact from address book via SMS - Error comes up that the interface is not supported. What? This is a basic feature of all mobile phones that I know of ie NOKIA and SONY

2. SMS is incomplete. No option for receiving a confirmation that the message has been delivered. This is a standard SMS feature on all GSM Phones.

3. When I make a call or receive a call I have the option to add the record. The Phonesoftware is not smart enough to open an existing record and just add the new number to an existing record

4. Overall the phone software is not smooth.

The PDA stuff is as good as it has always been on PALM. I last used PALM Vx. The address book, the calendar hardly have changed...

Reply to this comment

wifi

techno nerd @ 5/4/2006 5:40:57 PM # Q
dont know if this has already been said but, u can get wifi on the 650

http://www.hackaday.com/entry/1234000530023917/


Reply to this comment
Start a New Comment Thread Top

Account

Register Register | Login Log in
user:
pass: