MobileInfocenter

Comments on: Palm Touchstone Kit Review

Palm Touchstone ReviewThe Palm Touchstone is a charging dock that permits wireless recharging of the Palm Pre via induction technology. It is sold with the Touchstone Charging kit, which also includes the required soft touch back cover replacement. The accessory is available at launch with the Pre for $69.99 online and in stores.

Drastically different in both appearance and functionality and possessing much more pizzazz any of Palm's past accessory releases, the Palm Touchstone is a stunning little device in its own right that deserves a further look for anyone who is traditionally fond of desktop charging cradle solutions.

Read on for the full review.

Return to Story - Permalink

Article Comments

 (16 comments)

The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PalmInfocenter is not responsible for them in any way.
Please Login or register here to add your comments.

Start a new Comment Down

Spare battery charger?

philpalm @ 6/5/2009 7:36:41 PM # Q
So Ryan, can you charge a spare battery upon the touchstone separately or you will have to buy another battery charger for the spare?
RE: Spare battery charger?
Ryan @ 6/5/2009 7:44:46 PM # M Q
No, you must have the Pre connected (and the special back cover) to charge anything via the dock.

I imagine that this product would work, as the battery size/connectors are identical to the Centro.

http://software.palminfocenter.com/productaccessories.asp?id=22384

RE: Spare battery charger?
Marshall Flinkman @ 6/6/2009 2:04:12 PM # Q
I've said it before-Palm needs to release a spare battery charger to work with the Touchstone. Use the 800w one as a template (same size battery & it has the microUSB port for when the Touchstone may not be available) and add the magnet and inductive system.
Reply to this comment

Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm

LiveFaith @ 6/5/2009 7:55:02 PM # Q
Palm has done precious little in the past few years to create excitement. The touchstone creates an intrigue factor for their revival that will probably attract thousands to the device.

As you said, it's cool, but other than that I cannot fathom paying $70 for a charger that ties up my USB cable too. It's nice that it has an angle to it, but Palm has not taken opportunity yet to do NEAT thing with the device while it leans on the stone.

Qs?
1, I heard reported that charging was much slower than with the mUSB. Did you notice any speed difference?

2. Can devs get to the code to cause various responses when loading / unloading / or haing "events" on the touchstone?

3. Any idea if the Eos etc will be able to "get stoned"?

Killer review!
Pat Horne

RE: Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm
twrock @ 6/5/2009 8:38:28 PM # Q
"Get stoned!" Palm's new slogan. It'll be appearing everywhere soon.

Pat, quick, get a copyright on that puppy. Then you can sue the pants off of Palm when they try to steal it. I'll vouch for you in court.

Hey Palm! Where's my PDA with Wifi and phone capabilities?

RE: Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm
Ryan @ 6/5/2009 9:09:41 PM # Q
Thanks Pat. 1. I did not notice a significant difference but it was only slightly slower than going into the wall. Unfortunately, I didn't get a chance to time the difference. 2 & 3. I am not certain, but would hope so.
RE: Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm
bigredgpk @ 6/5/2009 10:43:42 PM # Q
Would you want to get the Treo 800w compact charger? It has the Micro USB charger plug like the Pre. If you get teh Centro version it'll have the old Palm Charger plug
RE: Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm
SeldomVisitor @ 6/6/2009 4:06:46 AM # Q
Palm says don't use any charger but the Pre charger.

Somewhere (probably TreoCentral forums) I read that the charger itself controls the charging (as opposed to simply being a transformer) to limit charging when the battery is full, thus stopping the "exploding battery" syndrome. Of course, I have no personal evidence of that but that's what I read. And Palm DOES say don't use any charger other than the Pre charger...

RE: Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm
Skykeeper @ 6/6/2009 3:49:27 PM # Q
"Since it does not come with a spare USB cable, you must use the one that comes with the Pre along with the electrical plug."

So... how much is the spare Pre USB cable? Or is it a standard USB cable?

(... sometimes company use very tight design that doesn't let you use standard usb cable, because the plastic around the connectors are too thick)

Thank you for your reply.

RE: Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm
Skykeeper @ 6/6/2009 4:33:18 PM # Q
BTW.. just realized that you needed a charger too to connect the touchstone... can't see any for sale... except car chargers ?!
RE: Intrigue Factor a Hit for Palm
SeldomVisitor @ 6/6/2009 4:48:57 PM # Q
The Pre travel charger (same as that with the Pre) costs $35.

Reply to this comment

Good hardware, needs software update.

alanh @ 6/7/2009 12:40:45 PM # Q
I bought a Touchstone and I always preferred using a cradle with my Palm devices. I really like the Touchstone concept. It's easy to use and is much easier than fumbling around with cables. I feel they need to improve the software in a few ways:

1. Let me configure the screen dimming perhaps all the way to "off." I keep my phone next to my bed when I sleep, and the current setting is brighter than I'd prefer.

2. Allow me to disable the "I've been put on a Touchstone" alert sound.

3. Make some changes in the "I'm sitting on a Touchstone" screen. Make it aware of the orientation of the device and rotate the clock accordingly. Put some indication of how charged the battery is on the screen.

It's a great first iteration and I don't think the hardware needs any update.
-alan

RE: Good hardware, needs software update.
jca666us @ 6/7/2009 6:36:19 PM # Q
A good number of early adopters are reporting "splotchy," distorted, or discolored displays (we've seen reports of dead pixels, too, though we'd actually be more weirded out if there weren't). See examples here, here, and here.
We've also heard reports of unexpected system shutdowns (like those reported in the LAPTOP piece above) that require a battery pull to resolve. We're hearing that you can also patch this up by holding down the power button and toggling the ringer switch three times, but your mileage may vary. If we had to guess, this'll be fixed up with a firmware update at some point, which really drives home the value of OTA capability.
Text fields in the web browser don't seem to support symbols that aren't on the keyboard (that is, symbols you need to hold down "Sym" to access). We've independently verified this one, and it's nasty - it'll be particularly bad once the phone launches internationally, so we'd also expect this to be patched sooner rather than later.
Reply to this comment

Touchstone Charger

keepmyjob @ 6/10/2009 12:51:50 PM # Q
Does anyone know whose partner in technology Palm used for the charger?
Reply to this comment

Charging inconsistent, should have come with own cable

realbrick @ 6/10/2009 2:02:52 PM # Q
Every time I put my Pre on this thing, there is a bit of suspense: will it start charging, or will it do nothing. About one time out of three, it does nothing. Very annoying - hopefully something Palm can fix with an update.

Also, ridiculous that a $70 device doesn't come with a way to plug it into the wall. You have to use the wall charger/USB cord that comes with your Pre to hook up the Touchstone!

So when you travel, or you want to charge at a different location, OR if you simply want to transfer files from your PC (that uses the same wire), you have to completely dismantle your Touchstone charger setup. Palm really screwed up the customer experience, here. They should send everyone who bought the Touchstone a wall plug/mini USB cord for free.

Do not buy this until 1) they fix the sometimes-it-doesn't-charge problem; 2) it comes with a way to plug it into the wall.

Reply to this comment

Not to be left out...

twrock @ 6/24/2009 4:57:03 AM # Q
Yep, get one for your iPhone:
http://www.engadgetmobile.com/2009/06/24/wireless-charging-comes-to-apples-iphone-3gs-too/

What's that? It costs even more than the Touchstone?!!!!

Oh yeah, that's right, it's for an Apple product. Silly me. ;-)

Hey Palm! Where's my PDA with Wifi and phone capabilities?

Reply to this comment
Start a New Comment Thread Top

Account

Register Register | Login Log in
user:
pass: