EFF Targets Nintendo Emulator Patent

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has announced the "Top 10 Most Wanted Patents" the organization will target first in it's campaign to rid the world of frivolous patent infringement lawsuits. A Nintendo patent that threatens current Palm OS and other Emulators is among those targeted.

After sifting through dozens of software and Internet-related patents submitted to its patent busting contest, EFF targeted ten whose crimes have made them enemies of the public domain. All the most-wanted patents are dangerously overbroad; many pose a threat to freedom of expression online. And every single one of the targeted patents is held by an entity that has threatened or brought lawsuits against small businesses, individuals, or nonprofits.

Among the top ten list is a patent awarded to Nintendo regarding software implementation of a handheld videogame hardware platform. The US Patent (6,672,963), effectively makes any unauthorized Nintendo emulator illegal in the United States and threatens any reverse engineering of videogames to promote interoperability and emulation by hobbyists.

The company has used claims under this patent threatening Palm OS developers Crimson Fire Entertainment and Gambit Studios with their patent on emulation of handheld games on low-power portable devices.

EFF's team of lawyers and technologists will be preparing to petition the Patent and Trademark Office for revocation of these offenders' patents. EFF's team of lawyers, technologists, and experts will now begin to research and collect prior art. Prior art is hard evidence that a patent is "obvious" because it is based on a commonly known idea or because the claimed "invention" actually existed before the patent was filed. Once the team has gathered enough prior art on a given patent, EFF will submit a petition to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in a legal process known as "reexamination." If the USPTO finds the prior art compelling, it will formally revoke the patent and release the idea back into the public domain, where it belongs.

"Patents are meant to protect companies against giant competitors, not to help them prey on folks who can barely afford a lawyer," said EFF Staff Attorney Jason Schultz, who leads the Patent Busting Project. "We hope our project will not only assist the victims of these abusive patents but also help make the case for global reform of the patent system."

Article Comments


The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PalmInfocenter is not responsible for them in any way.
Please Login or register here to add your comments.

Comments Closed Comments Closed
This article is no longer accepting new comments.


Liberty / Freedom

killah fury @ 7/7/2004 5:08:31 PM #
I'm still patiently waiting Gambit Studios to release the new version of Liberty (Freedom) for Palm OS 5...

RE: Liberty / Freedom
maven @ 7/8/2004 12:09:55 AM #
I can only apologize for the delay, and hope along with everyone else that we can get our "differences" with Nintendo resolved soon.

We are gratified that the EFF agree with our stance on Nintendos recent patent, and we believe they will be able to strike down this frivolous patent.

We do not believe Liberty even violates the patent, and if it did it would then be classified as "prior art". However, Nintendo's lawyers have so far not agreed with our IP attorneys' evaluation.

It's "David -vs- Goliath" and our stones aren't doing the job just yet.

RE: Liberty / Freedom
eamondaly @ 7/8/2004 3:43:06 PM #
No need to apologize. As a registered user, I hope you take whatever time you need to get your legal ducks in a row.


Register Register | Login Log in