|
    RealOne Player Officially DebutsPosted By: Ryan on Monday, March 17, 2003 7:58:11 PM
The RealOne Player Mobile for the Palm Tungsten T is now officially available. RealOne Mobile Player enables RealAudio and MP3 audio support for the Tungsten T handheld. The RealOne Player Mobile enables consumers to:
Palm Tungsten T handheld users can now download the program here. The RealOne Mobile Player also will be shipped with select future Palm handhelds. The application requires at least 500k of free memory. Audio Files are detected in the following SD Card Subdirectories: SD_Audio, RN_Audio and AUDIO. If you haven't already, It is recommended you install the audio update patch for the Tungsten T. The patch addresses and improve sound quality issues when playing back digital audio files.
More Stories Like This...  Mobiscope Webcam Monitor Released for Palm OS Kinoma Player EX v4.5 Released Resco Suite for Palm OS Updated Idea-Jot-It 2.0 Released ptpChat Now Available As Freeware mySchedule NHL 2008 Released More articles about Software
Article Comments
47 total comments The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PIC is not responsible for them in any way. login or register for free in order to post comments.
 So, does this only work with the TT?I.M Anonymous @ 3/17/2003 9:06:41 PM #
And if it does, does that mean that it uses the TT's DSP?  RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
Yes, it's only for the Tungsten T at this point, not sure about the DSP. RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
No, it doesn't use the DSP any more than the other two players. Decoding of the MP3 is handled by the ARM core. Raw stream playback is handled by the DSP. Same as Aeroplayer and Pocket-Tunes. RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
DSP is only for the actual audio playback, not decoding. The audio APIs for the Tungsten play via the DSP chip... so it would take extra work to make it NOT use DSP.. and I cannot fathom why anyone would want to do that. Decoding the format (MP3 or whatever) is best left for the ARM processor.. and if it is done in native ARM, should be plenty fast for the decode. RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
Well, if it is only desined for the ARM cpu's, why can't this work on the Clie NX/NZ series? RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
>Well, if it is only desined [sic] for the ARM cpu's, why can't this work on the Clie NX/NZ series? Sony didn't implement the OS 5 sampled sound manager on the NX; you can use the ARM CPU to decode mp3's, but there's no official way to get the results to the speaker. RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
> Decoding the format (MP3 or whatever) is best left for the ARM processor. RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
someone wrote: > Decoding the format (MP3 or whatever) is best left for the ARM processor. Not necessarily true. The C5XX DSP inside the OMAP might be able to do mp3 decoding faster and using less battery power than the ARM9 CPU. The DSP runs at a higher clock rate (200 MHz vs. 144 MHz) and has much faster multipliers. You could put mp3 playing in the background with much less of a slow down of the foreground app. RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
So is there any plan from any mp3 player that uses the DSP chip on the Tungsten for mp3 decoding? Tony RE: So, does this only work with the TT?
"So is there any plan from any mp3 player that uses the DSP chip on the Tungsten for mp3 decoding?"
This is wholly dependent on Palm SG. PalmSource has implemented an Extended sound call in OS 5.2 now which can offload both decode and play functions to a stream. However, it's up to the hardware makers to implement it for their hardware. If they updated their halsnd_dsplib to include support for MP3 and/or OGG decode and playback, then the software makers could update their MP3 players to support it. 
Killed the cat
Just out of curiosity, is this better or worse than AeroPlayer/Pocket Tunes? -Bosco Proud Member of the Top Non-Mods Members: abosco and ImpReza M3 Now accepting new applications RE: Killed the cat
Quality is roughly the same. Interface from an actual usability perspective is poorer than both, AFAIC. If you don't own either, the Linux download will give you a free player without Real's desktop, but considering that both the pay solutions for the T|T are about on par with the included players in other PDAs, this one will undoubtedly draw derision from other PDA owners (that's not even taking into account sound quality). RE: Killed the cat
AeroPlayer is the best. I have used Real beta and final and it sux. Aero has great skin support and playlist accessible right away. Pocket tunes has a bad playlist. RE: Killed the cat
And remember... AeroPlayer is free if you don't want/need MP3 playback (OGG is better, thank you very much). RE: Killed the cat
> And remember... AeroPlayer is free if you don't want/need MP3 playback (OGG is better, thank you very much). OGG will not be "better" than MP3 until the majority of portable music players support OGG. The vast majority of consumers still use MP3, and regardless of audio encoding, MP3 is the standard. RE: Killed the cat
"better" is subjective. I believe he was talking about "better" sounding or "better" compressed. In that case, Ogg could be "better" than MP3. MP3 is far more universal. That could be "better" too. Depends on the viewpoint. _____ Fammy RE: Killed the cat
Nikman, you mentioned... "AeroPlayer is the best. I have used Real beta and final and it sux. Aero has great skin support and playlist accessible right away. Pocket tunes has a bad playlist." I would agree that AeroPlayer and Pocket Tunes are superior to the Real One Player. At the same time, I would pick Pocket Tunes over AeroPlayer. With the latest version (1.7.2), Pocket Tunes supports playlists. In addition, Pocket Tunes is faster navigating through the playlists and changing playlists. I also like the options you have for accessing the control pad in Pocket Tunes while in other applications. Another big plus for me, Pocket Tunes does not crash when downloading messages on my TT using VersaMail via Bluetooth. All in all, it is a matter of preference, but Pocket Tunes is worth a look. I prefer it! You might, too! As always, just my humble opinion... RE: Killed the cat
I think OGG is better because it's free :). Anyway, I use Linux, and I'm perfectly happy with converting to Ogg. Although I used MP3s (and have a car MP3 player and portable MP3 devices), I seem to be slowly switching to Ogg, especially with support now on my Zaurus and now on my Tungsten T. I wish Sony would support Ogg too... it doesn't cost them any per unit price.
Prelimary Performance Comparison with Aeroplayer
Hi, I've performed a brief performance comparison of RealOne Player with AeroPlayer. While playing music in background, the Aeroplayer consumes less CPU power and the foreground applications run much less chunky. For one particular video clips, I played mp3 in background with each audio player and measures the playback performance of the Kinoma Player. Here's the result for one particular mp3 file and one particular video clip, AeroPlayer RealPlayer Tony RE: Prelimary Performance Comparison with Aeroplayer
I got similar results using the program "Benchmark" by Quartus. It measures speed compared to a stock Palm V I think. No player: 275% I don't have AeroPlayer right now but that was almost identical to PocketTunes. Real's shortcoming is probably due to a low-pass filter that seems to cut off pretty much everything above 17kHz. See http://www.palminfocenter.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=11760 for charts. RE: Prelimary Performance Comparison with Aeroplayer
Look at the desktop version. That, too, is a resource hog. I didn't expect their Palm version to be any different. RE: Prelimary Performance Comparison with Aeroplayerdavechalmers @ 3/21/2003 3:43:21 AM #
Hey! my brand new T T is only running 255%!!
I've been cheated!! :-) Seriously, how do I find out if there is stuff running in the background, that is slowing things down? Dave
I am confused...
Didn't this come out the other day? I clicked on the link in the recent PIC quickies and downloaded this thing and have it on my T|T now. Did I miss something or is this just the official press rollout? --Jon RE: I am confused...
Although it has been on Real's site for a number of days, this is the 'official' release announcement.
Has a couple of advantages
Although i don't understand how it is that a company with the resources that Real has (and presumably with the ability to tap Palm SG for help), can't seem to come up with a product that performs as efficiently as Aeroplayer or PocketTunes (both by small companies), there are none-the-less, a couple of advantages: its free and it plays RealAudio format. The ability to play real audio is something that is perhaps more usefull on PDAs then it is on the desktop because memory tends to be more of a precious commodity - and .ra files can be considerably smaller then mp3s. Hopefully they fix the performance issue and get on with adding video to the feature-set. RE: Has a couple of advantages
Yes, the proud goes to the authors of AeroPlayer and PocketTunes. It's hard to see the performance of the RealOne Player, when it's got partnerships and technical information directly from Palm.com. Not to mention its 4-month delay.
I would feel happier if they also add the streaming features of audio files. Tony
So where is the Mac version?????
A .sit file wouldn't have taken them very long to do. iTunes support would be nice, but I guess would have taken a little longer given that lack of documentation from Apple, but come on Real, I'm prepared to use HotSync to copy the files, slow as it is! RE: So where is the Mac version?????
Just tried the mac link on the download page repeatedly. It's busted! Us Mac users are strictly 3rd class citizens... RE: So where is the Mac version?????
Just download the Linux version, it's the same as the Mac download just ZIPPED instead of STUFFED.
Why only audio?
I'm really disappointed. This is a fine audio player for me, and I wouldn't pay for a better one, but I was expecting video playback. The RealOne Mobile Player even plays video clips on the Nokia Communicator. Why not on my Tungsten|T? RE: Why only audio?JonathanChoo @ 3/18/2003 7:08:03 AM #
Well, it works as advertised. So there. However, yeah I do wish they have video support - but being a RealPlayer that would be crappy Real format. I heard that work has already begin in porting Pocket MVP (a multimedia player for PocketPC capable of playing Ogg, DivX and other formats) to PalmOS. Current gadgets: Palm Tungsten T, HP Ipaq h5455, Ericsson T68 Screw Bush & Blair RE: Why only audio?Stratman25 @ 3/18/2003 10:18:00 AM #
Try Tealpoint's Tealmovie. It's OS 5 compatible and plays movies great (as I can expect from a PDA). RE: Why only audio?
Actually, you should try Kinoma if you really want to see how well movies play on a TT. The converter is 4 times faster and there's never a sound sync problem in the player RE: Why only audio?
>>Actually, you should try Kinoma if you really want to see how well movies play on a TT.
Yep - Tealmovie kind of blows by comparison. What i'm really waiting for is a player that will play avi & divx natively from the memory card. I'm sure we will see this soon - hopefully for free.
Real one leaves crud on your palm after being deleted
I did a quick install of the real one before deciding Aeroplayer is better but after deleting Real One I found one maybe more files which were leftovers and could not be removed without some work RealOne_RNWK_app size 84 b for certain I was able to remove the file with a file management program but only after a soft reset. Guess they are having a tough time breaking old habits got to leave a foot print behind when they have been on your machine It's worth the money to regiter Areoplayer just to know these guys are not in my system. RE: Real one leaves crud on your palm after being deleted
Is this not the stub that the Palm OS5 creates for EVERY installed app? And doesn't always delete when you delete the app?
For me this is the main problem with th 345 file problenm: with 100 installed apps one would have 200 files already... Am I right about this?
Streaming file capture?Stratman25 @ 3/18/2003 2:55:38 PM #
Does anyone have a solution for capturing streaming Real Audio files on the Palm? I know it's not supported by RealPlayer, but I wonder if anyone has tried this with any success.
Sound Volume Issues
Hi Just got Real Player and the Palm T Audio patch. Quality is good, especially on 192k MP3's. The only issue is that the sound volume doesn't go loud enough. On the train etc. it can be difficult to hear. Any ideas? Are there any third party apps that can amplify the volume. I know Aero Player has a +5db option. Has anyone used this feature?? Peter
Only the first 40 comments are displayed with the article.
|
 Special Deals
Shop at Amazon and help support PalmInfocenter
|
||||
PalmInfocenter.com is not affiliated with or endorsed by Palm Inc, Access or PalmSource in any way.
Any use of the word Palm is for discussion purposes and is a registered trademark of Palm Inc.
Unauthorized reproduction of content is strictly forbidden.
© MobileInfocenter.com, all rights reserved.
The RealOne Player Mobile for the Tungsten T handheld is based on the Helix DNA Client, a software engine that device manufacturers and software developers can use to build a multiformat media player for any device. RealNetworks is working with the Helix Community to make the Helix DNA Client available for the Palm OS 5 platform, which will enable other media applications to be developed for the Tungsten T handheld and other Palm handhelds.
