Comments on: Microsoft Awarded Button Clicking Patent
Article Comments
(48 comments)
The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. PalmInfocenter is not responsible for them in any way.
Please Login or register here to add your comments.
Comments Closed
This article is no longer accepting new comments.
RE: Ridiculous
JW
RE: Ridiculous
At least when my patent was done, they did some serious research first. Too bad that is no longer the case. Guess it depends on how good your patent attorneys are...
RE: Ridiculous
RE: Ridiculous
Also, some buttons cause the functions of *other* buttons to change.
How much does Mazda owe Microsoft for these heretofore supposedly un-thought-of innovations?
RE: Ridiculous
RE: Ridiculous
"Other References
Applications Handbook for the Palm III.TM. Organizer, 3Com Corporation, 1998.
Handbook for the Palm III.TM. Organizer, 3Com Corporation, 1998. "
Taken from patent details page, link in article above.
I didn't realize that things like hold/repeat character and calculator buttons and such were subject to patents.
But hey, what do I know, supposedly the Treo keyboard infringed RIM's patent.
RE: Ridiculous
"Obviously, innovation at it's best"
RE: Ridiculous
RE: Ridiculous
The Federation for the Responsible Use of Acronyms
RE: Ridiculous
No, not software. Mine is a utility patent for a speaker design which is now going through the marketing process. You should be able to buy them in pro audio stores sometime next year if all goes well.
RE: Ridiculous
Sounds like M$ has a bulletproof patent here. Is M$ getting desperate?
Pat Horne; www.churchoflivingfaith.com
RE: Ridiculous
I do not own a cellular phone, pointless for my purposes. If I am not mistaken, the numeric keypad is pressed in rapid succession in a given time period to type letters for e-mail or text messages. Maybe Microsoft shall be receiving royalties from cellular phone companies as well for using this multiple clicking of buttons to type letters.
RE: Ridiculous
Think of all the playgrounds that are violating this patent!
RE: Ridiculous
RE: Ridiculous
1.) You do not buy OpenOffice.org as it is free. (Windows, linux and Mac versions available) However, it would not be free if you order it on CD instead of doing a download.
2.) Personal experience leads me to advise you not to try Red Hat's Fedora Core 1.1 (Red Hat 9 might be fine). On two computers, floppy drive was disabled for me and shaky USB support. My CD drive on the VAIO was giving errors too. I recommend and use Mandrake Linux. It works well and even supports my linksys wireless card with no setup, true plug and play.
I personally prefer Linux, but Mac makes a close second (not to mention Linux takes much longer to start). Macintosh simply offers more software and games. I would continue, but this should not be longer as it veers off the main topic. If someone wants more, start a Linux vs. Windows topic in the discussion forum, I would likely find it sooner or later.
--------------------------
In case you did not know, the stop signs with the white border are NOT optional.
RE: Ridiculous
In the heat of battle, no body wins.
~ "Don't be too proud of this technological terror you've constructed." - DV ~
RE: Ridiculous
Cheers,
Now that's news, isn't it!
ROFL,
- Harkonnen
RE: Now that's news, isn't it!
;)
Part of the description reads; "Press and hold the Datebook button."
RE: Now that's news, isn't it!
*sigh*
Many apps already do this!
RE: Many apps already do this!
RE: Many apps already do this!
What is wrong with these patent people? I'm sick of it. Who's with me in stating, "THIS ACTION WILL NOT STAND". How about a class action lawsuit against the patent office?
---
David
Palm Backlight....
Hmmm, I guess Palm missed the boat on this patent. Oh wait, things like this have been done for a LONG time.
Palm repairs and upgrades
www.pdaspecialists.com
US Patents are like confetti
http://www.siliconvalley.com/mld/siliconvalley/3084451.htm
This is just another example. It won't stand up in court. The only real shame is that the US Patent office is underfunded, but independent lawyers are making a fat profit from this pointless system.
Microsoft Patents Dumping
RE: Microsoft Patents Dumping
RE: Microsoft Patents Dumping
In fact, you posting is also an infringement of my patent, no one can post on a forum without paying me a royalty of $50 prior to posting...
PAY UP!
lol, sorry i just couldn't control myself
RE: Microsoft Patents Dumping
I would be indignant, but that's pending. ;)
RE: Microsoft Patents Dumping
-------------------------------
Microsoft is the root of all evil.
Right, Bill?
RE: Microsoft Patents Dumping
(Self-confessed Palm Geek)
I have a feeling that...
It makes sense.
I bet Billy has joined a whole team of realy creative people whom are trying to fetch as much of 'realy kewl ideas' to patent.
RE: I have a feeling that...
Checkout "More Stories Like This..." above
Wrong button sequences
Now that's real innovation...microsoft style...
RE: Wrong button sequences
This just in... Microsoft patents the state of Washington. Microsoft sues Oregon and Idaho for infringement.
Could Mr. Bill be related to Christopher Columbus? They're both good at discoverning things that other people already knew about.
Microsoft put the "butt" in buttons.
Aric Tucker
Stepshows.com
RE: Wrong button sequences
__
/erry
There's a lot of FUD being spread here...
Interestingly, it looks like 3Com originated the patent and then let it expire in 1999. Microsoft then filed the continuation. Palm manuals are cited as reference materials in the patent.
RE: There's a lot of FUD being spread here...
If that is the case then I suggest we all haunt the patent expiry listing like hawks looking for gems we had no hand in but would like to benefit from in the future.
Something has got to be wrong with a patent system that allows this, if it is the case.
RE: There's a lot of FUD being spread here...
This Idea is 167 years old!
RE: This Idea is 167 years old!
The telegraph is an even better example of prior art.
~ "Don't be too proud of this technological terror you've constructed." - DV ~
Latest Comments
- I got one -Tuckermaclain
- RE: Don't we have this already? -Tuckermaclain
- RE: Palm brand will return in 2018, with devices built by TCL -richf
- RE: Palm brand will return in 2018, with devices built by TCL -dmitrygr
- Palm phone on HDblog -palmato
- Palm PVG100 -hgoldner
- RE: Like Deja Vu -PacManFoo
- Like Deja Vu -T_W
Ridiculous